Why Encouragement Can Be Bad For Business
People in business get used to handling criticism. But encouragement is a different can of worms.
Not only does it bypass the muscles we grow to deal with challenges, it hits extra hard precisely because of all those challenges. Sort of like how even bad fast food tastes good when you haven’t eaten all day.
Finally, some kind words! Finally, somebody recognizes that my idea is good!
When encouragement comes from people who know us and support us, it’s easy to absorb. Of course my friend wants me to succeed. He wouldn’t be saying my business concept is great if he thought it would blow up in my face and I’d lose my life savings. But wanting what’s best for someone and actually giving helpful advice are two different things.
The encouragement of people who don’t know us is powerful in a different way. They come across as objective observers with nothing to gain by being nice, which makes them seem more credible. But a few kind words cost a stranger almost nothing, and taken too much to heart, they can throw you off course.
Encouragement Can Bypass Critical Thinking
Friends and family who say, “You bake great cakes, you should open a bakery” mean well but their words should factor very little into such a decision. They’re not thinking about whether you’d enjoy baking 60 hours a week, or the cost of a lease, or what you’d be giving up to pursue it. The encouragement skips straight from “you’re good at this” to “you should build your life around it” with nothing in between.
There’s also a common attitude of “just give it a try, what’s the worst that could happen?” But there are an infinite number of things you could try. That alone isn’t a reason to do any particular one of them. Especially when “trying” means investing a lot of your time and money, not the time and money of the cheerleader. When somebody knows you for five minutes and encourages you to “follow your passion,” this might be pleasant, but it’s not valuable advice.
And once you’ve acted on someone’s encouragement, it develops its own momentum. You’ve told people about it, maybe spent money, maybe turned down other opportunities. Now you’re not just pursuing an idea, you’re defending a decision. The encouragement that got you started has long since evaporated, but you’re still living with the consequences.
There’s also a subtler version of this. Someone suggests an idea you aren’t interested in, and suddenly you’re in the position of explaining why you’re not doing it. “You like Roman history, you should start a YouTube channel about Rome.” Now instead of working on your business, you’re having a conversation about why you don’t want to start a YouTube channel. Other people’s enthusiasm for their idea of what you should do can become its own distraction, even if you never act on it.
Enjoy the kind words. Then make your decisions without them.
Results, Not Cheerleading
If you need writing done for you, contact me. I’m here to help.






